Skip to main content

Sellers

What Happens When a Buyer Asks for Repairs After the Inspection?

By Billy Deese — Owner / Designated Broker

Published Updated

What Happens When a Buyer Asks for Repairs After the Inspection?

A buyer's inspection doesn't automatically mean you have to fix everything they find. Learn what can happen after the inspection, how repair requests and negotiations work, and how to decide whether to repair, negotiate, say no, or consider another solution.

You accepted an offer.

The buyer completed their inspection.

And now you've received a list of things they want you to fix.

Maybe it's two things.

Maybe it's twenty-two.

Before you start calling contractors, or getting angry, there's something important to understand:

An inspection report is not automatically a repair list.

The buyer has learned more about the property. What happens next depends on the purchase agreement, the buyer's response, your response, and what the parties ultimately agree to.

What Is the Buyer Actually Asking For?

Start by reading the buyer's response carefully.

There's a big difference between an inspector mentioning something in a report and a buyer actually requesting that you do something about it.

Inspection reports can contain dozens of observations. The buyer may only care about a handful of them.

Focus on the actual request rather than reacting to every item the inspector identified.

Do I Have to Fix Everything the Buyer Requests?

Not necessarily.

Your obligations and options depend on the purchase agreement and the circumstances of the transaction.

A buyer can request something.

That doesn't automatically mean you have to agree to it.

Depending on the contract, you may be able to agree, decline, negotiate, or propose another solution.

The buyer may also have rights under their inspection contingency.

This is a negotiation governed by the contract, not a rule that says the seller has to make the house perfect.

What Kinds of Things Do Buyers Usually Care About?

Every buyer is different, but significant issues tend to receive more attention than cosmetic ones.

Things like structural concerns, roofing problems, electrical hazards, plumbing leaks, sewer issues, water intrusion, heating systems, or other expensive or safety-related problems may affect a buyer's willingness or ability to proceed.

That doesn't mean every older component needs to be replaced.

An old furnace that works is different from a furnace that doesn't work.

An older roof is different from an actively leaking roof.

Condition matters.

So does the buyer's financing, insurance situation, tolerance for repairs, and the terms of the agreement.

Should I Just Agree to the Repairs?

Maybe.

But first, figure out what you're agreeing to.

How much will it cost?

Who will perform the work?

Can it reasonably be completed before closing?

Will permits be required?

Could opening up the problem reveal something larger?

Will the repair need to meet a particular standard?

Don't agree to “repair electrical issue” without understanding what the issue is and what the repair might involve.

Get information before making a decision.

Could I Offer Money Instead?

Sometimes the parties may prefer a financial solution rather than having the seller complete the work.

That might involve a negotiated credit, price adjustment, or another structure allowed by the contract and the buyer's financing.

But this needs to be coordinated properly.

A seller can't necessarily hand the buyer money on the side at closing.

Lenders may have rules regarding credits and concessions, and the transaction documents need to accurately reflect the agreement.

If money is part of the solution, make sure the buyer's lender and closing professionals are involved when appropriate.

Why Might a Buyer Prefer a Credit?

Buyers sometimes prefer to handle repairs themselves after closing.

Maybe they want to choose the contractor.

Maybe they're planning a larger renovation anyway.

Maybe they'd rather control how the work is completed.

And frankly, a seller who is leaving the house may have a very different definition of “good enough” than the person who's about to own it.

A financial solution can sometimes avoid that problem.

But again, financing rules and the purchase agreement matter.

Why Might a Seller Prefer to Make the Repair?

Sometimes repairing the problem is cleaner.

If a significant issue could affect the transaction, future buyers, financing, or insurance, fixing it may remove the obstacle altogether.

It may also give you more control over the actual cost instead of negotiating based on what somebody thinks the repair might cost.

If you're considering a substantial repair, getting a written estimate can be extremely helpful.

Now you're negotiating around an actual number instead of fear.

Can I Just Say No?

Potentially.

But understand what happens if you do.

Depending on the buyer's inspection rights and the contract, declining a request could mean the buyer accepts the property anyway.

It could lead to further negotiation.

Or the buyer may have the ability to terminate the transaction.

The fact that you can say no doesn't necessarily mean saying no is the best financial decision.

And the fact that you're afraid of losing the buyer doesn't mean you should automatically say yes.

Look at the entire situation.

How Should I Decide Whether to Agree?

Start with the cost of the request.

Then consider the significance of the issue.

How much is the repair likely to cost?

Is the buyer's request reasonable in light of the problem?

Could this issue affect another buyer if this transaction falls apart?

Would you likely need to disclose the issue going forward?

How strong is the current offer?

How difficult would it be to put the home back on the market?

How much will delaying the sale cost you?

Sometimes spending $1,500 to keep an otherwise excellent transaction together is an easy decision.

Sometimes a buyer is asking for $20,000 worth of work on a house that was already priced to reflect its condition.

Those are very different negotiations.

Be Careful About Letting Emotion Take Over

Inspection negotiations can get weirdly personal.

“I already gave them a good deal.”

“They knew the house was old.”

“I can't believe they're asking for that.”

Maybe.

But the buyer isn't evaluating how hard you've worked on the house over the last fifteen years.

They're deciding whether they still want to purchase it based on what they know now.

Try to treat the inspection response as a business decision.

What does the request cost?

What happens if you agree?

What happens if you don't?

Which outcome puts you in the best position?

That's much more useful than deciding whether the buyer has offended you.

What If the Inspector Is Wrong?

Inspectors can identify conditions that deserve further evaluation, but they aren't necessarily specialists in every trade.

If a report raises a major concern, it may make sense to obtain an opinion or estimate from an appropriately qualified professional.

A sentence in an inspection report might sound like a $15,000 problem.

A specialist might determine it's a $900 repair.

Or the specialist might determine it's considerably worse than anyone initially thought.

Either way, better information helps you negotiate intelligently.

What Happens If We Agree to Repairs?

Get the agreement in writing.

The contract or appropriate written modification should clearly identify what the parties agreed to do.

Then complete the work as required and keep documentation.

Invoices, receipts, permits when required, and other records can help establish what was actually completed.

Don't wait until the morning of closing to discover that the contractor never showed up.

What If the Buyer Finds Something Really Serious?

Sometimes an inspection uncovers a significant problem nobody knew about.

Foundation damage.

Major water intrusion.

A failed sewer line.

Serious electrical issues.

At that point, the conversation may become bigger than one buyer's repair request.

Even if the current transaction doesn't close, you now have information about the property that may affect what you do next and what you may need to disclose.

This is when getting appropriate professional advice becomes particularly important.

Don't Hide the Problem and Hope the Next Buyer Doesn't Find It

If a transaction fails because an inspection uncovers a serious issue, simply putting the house back on the market and pretending nothing happened can create bigger problems.

Washington sellers may have disclosure obligations concerning known property conditions.

What needs to be disclosed depends on the circumstances, but knowingly concealing a material problem is not a selling strategy.

Find out what your obligations are.

Then decide whether repairing the issue, adjusting the price, or selling with the condition disclosed makes the most sense.

The Goal Isn't to Win the Inspection Negotiation

It's tempting to think of negotiation as having a winner and a loser.

The seller gave up $3,000.

The buyer won.

Not necessarily.

If you sell the house at a price and on terms you're happy with, and the buyer gets a property they're comfortable purchasing, the transaction worked.

The goal is to make a good business decision.

Sometimes that means holding firm.

Sometimes it means fixing something.

Sometimes it means giving a little to keep a very good deal together.

And occasionally, it means letting a transaction go.

The Bottom Line

When a buyer asks for repairs after an inspection, don't panic and don't immediately agree to everything.

Understand what they're actually requesting.

Find out what the problem really is.

Get estimates when appropriate.

Review your contractual obligations and options.

Then look at the cost of solving the problem compared with the cost and risk of not solving it.

Inspection negotiations don't have to become a fight.

They're another decision in the process.

And we'll help you work through it.

We make it easy.

This article is for general educational purposes and isn't legal, inspection, engineering, lending, or construction advice. Inspection rights, disclosure obligations, repair agreements, and contractual deadlines depend on the specific transaction. Consult the appropriate professionals regarding your circumstances.

More on selling a home.

Start from the top of this topic: What Does It Cost to Sell a House in Spokane?

← Back to Ready to Sell