Skip to main content

Buyers

What Happens If the Appraisal Comes in Low?

By Billy Deese — Owner / Designated Broker

Published Updated

What Happens If the Appraisal Comes in Low?

A low appraisal doesn't automatically kill your home purchase. Learn why appraisals sometimes come in below the purchase price, what it means for your loan, and the options buyers and sellers may have to keep the transaction together.

Your offer was accepted.

You've made it through the inspection.

Financing is moving along.

Then your lender orders the appraisal.

The house you're buying for $500,000 appraises for $480,000.

Now what?

First: don't assume the deal is dead.

A low appraisal can create a problem that needs to be solved, but there may be several ways to solve it.

What Is an Appraisal?

An appraisal is an independent opinion of a property's value prepared by a qualified appraiser.

When you're financing a home, your lender may require an appraisal because the property is collateral for the mortgage.

The lender wants to know whether the property's value reasonably supports the loan being made.

The appraiser may consider the property's characteristics, condition, location, recent comparable sales and other relevant information when developing an opinion of value.

An appraisal is not simply somebody checking whether the purchase price looks reasonable.

The appraiser develops their own opinion based on the applicable appraisal process and available information.

Why Would a House Appraise Below the Purchase Price?

There are several possibilities.

Maybe buyers are willing to pay more than recent comparable sales would support.

Maybe there aren't many good comparable properties nearby.

Maybe the home has unusual features that are difficult to value.

Maybe the market has been moving quickly and closed sales haven't caught up with current buyer activity.

Or maybe the agreed-upon purchase price simply is higher than the appraiser believes the property is worth.

Remember, the purchase price and appraised value are two different things.

The purchase price is what a buyer and seller agreed to.

The appraisal is an opinion of value.

Sometimes they're the same.

Sometimes they aren't.

Does the Seller Have to Lower the Price?

Not automatically.

A low appraisal doesn't necessarily require the seller to reduce the purchase price.

The seller may still believe the home is worth the amount agreed upon.

What happens next depends on your purchase agreement, financing, any applicable appraisal or financing contingencies and what the buyer and seller are willing to do.

That's why it's important to look at the actual contract before deciding what options are available.

Can the Buyer Just Pay the Difference?

Possibly.

Suppose you agreed to purchase a home for $500,000 and it appraises for $480,000.

That doesn't necessarily mean you simply hand over an extra $20,000.

The effect on your required cash depends on the loan program, loan-to-value calculation, down payment and lender requirements.

Your lender needs to explain exactly how the lower appraisal changes your financing.

If additional cash would be required, you then decide whether bringing that money to closing makes sense for you.

You shouldn't assume that it does.

Can the Buyer and Seller Renegotiate?

Potentially, yes.

A buyer and seller may be able to negotiate a solution.

The seller might agree to reduce the price.

The buyer might agree to bring additional funds.

The parties might agree to meet somewhere in between.

There may be other adjustments that make the transaction work, depending on the financing and contract.

None of those outcomes is automatic.

It's a negotiation.

What If the Seller Won't Lower the Price?

Then the buyer has a decision to make.

Depending on the contract and financing, you may have the option to proceed at the existing price, negotiate another solution or potentially terminate the transaction under an applicable contingency.

But don't assume you can simply walk away because the appraisal was low.

Your rights depend on the agreement you signed.

This is one of those times when the exact language in the contract matters.

Can We Challenge the Appraisal?

There may be a process for raising legitimate concerns about an appraisal.

For example, there could be factual errors about the property or relevant comparable sales that deserve consideration.

Your lender can explain the applicable process for requesting a review or reconsideration of value.

That does not mean:

“We don't like the number, so please make it higher.”

There should be a legitimate basis for questioning the appraisal.

If the report says the home has two bedrooms when it actually has four, that's worth addressing.

If an appropriate comparable sale was overlooked, that may be worth raising.

But an appraiser isn't required to change the opinion simply because the transaction needs a higher value to work.

What If There Aren't Good Comparable Sales?

This can be particularly challenging with unusual properties.

Maybe the house has acreage.

A huge shop.

A unique view.

An unusual layout.

A substantial accessory structure.

Or it's located somewhere with very few recent comparable sales.

An appraiser still has to develop an opinion of value based on appropriate information and methodology.

Unique features can make that job more difficult because there may not be another property nearby that matches yours neatly.

That's one reason a seller's asking price, a buyer's offer and an appraised value can sometimes be different.

What Is an Appraisal Gap?

You may hear people use the phrase “appraisal gap.”

Generally, they're talking about the difference between the purchase price and the appraised value.

In competitive markets, some buyers may agree in advance to cover some or all of a potential appraisal shortfall.

That can strengthen an offer, but it can also increase the buyer's financial exposure.

If you're considering appraisal-gap language in an offer, make sure you understand exactly what you've agreed to and how much additional cash you could potentially need.

Don't agree to cover a $25,000 appraisal gap because it makes your offer look better if you don't actually have, or don't want to spend, the additional money.

Is Paying More Than the Appraised Value Always a Bad Idea?

Not necessarily.

An appraisal is an opinion of value, not a law that says nobody should ever pay a dollar more.

A buyer may decide a particular home is worth more to them because of its location, features, scarcity or other circumstances.

But if you're considering paying significantly more than the appraised value, understand what you're doing.

You're choosing to pay a price that exceeds that particular appraisal's opinion of value.

Ask yourself why.

Ask what it does to your cash position.

Ask whether you're comfortable with the possibility that you may not immediately have equity equal to the money you've invested.

Then make the decision intentionally.

What If the Appraisal Comes in Higher Than the Purchase Price?

Congratulations.

Generally, you don't have to call the seller and volunteer to pay more.

The purchase contract determines the price unless the parties agree to change it.

A higher appraisal also doesn't mean you've instantly made a guaranteed profit.

It's still an opinion of value, and future market value isn't guaranteed.

But from the standpoint of getting through the transaction, a value that supports the purchase price is usually much less exciting than one that doesn't.

And during a real estate transaction, boring can be wonderful.

Don't Panic Before Talking to Your Lender

If the appraisal comes in low, the first thing we want to understand is the actual problem.

What was the appraised value?

How does that affect the loan?

Does the lender require anything to change?

What does the contract say?

What deadlines apply?

What options are available?

Then we can start discussing solutions.

A $10,000 appraisal shortfall doesn't necessarily mean a buyer needs another $10,000.

And it doesn't necessarily mean the seller needs to reduce the price by $10,000.

We need the numbers before we decide what the problem actually costs.

The Bottom Line

A low appraisal isn't good news.

But it isn't automatically the end of the transaction either.

The buyer, seller, lender and the terms of the purchase agreement all matter.

Sometimes the price changes.

Sometimes the buyer brings additional money.

Sometimes the parties compromise.

Sometimes an appraisal issue is legitimately reconsidered.

And sometimes the parties can't reach a solution.

Our job is not to panic when a number comes back differently than expected.

It's to understand what that number actually changes, know what the contract allows and work through the available options.

One problem at a time.

We make it easy.

This article is for general educational purposes and isn't legal, lending, financial or appraisal advice. Appraisal requirements, financing consequences and contractual rights vary by transaction. Consult the appropriate professionals regarding your specific purchase.

More on buying a home.

Start from the top of this topic: How Much House Can I Afford in Spokane?

← Back to Just Looking