Skip to main content

Sellers

What Happens If My House Appraises Low?

By Billy Deese — Owner / Designated Broker

Published Updated

A real estate professional standing outside a house reviewing paperwork on a clipboard
Photo by Pavel Danilyuk / Pexels (pexels.com/photo/7937217)

What happens if your house appraises below the contract price? Learn what a low appraisal means for a seller, whether you have to lower the price, and the options that may keep the sale together.

Your agent calls.

“The appraisal came in low.”

Awesome.

You had a buyer willing to pay $525,000 for your house, and now somebody you have never met has apparently decided it is worth $500,000.

The first question most sellers ask is:

Do I have to lower my price?

No. Not automatically.

An appraisal does not rewrite your purchase agreement by itself.

But if the buyer is financing the purchase, a low appraisal can affect how much the lender is willing to lend, which can create a problem the buyer and seller have to solve.

Whether you actually need to change the price depends on the buyer's loan, the appraisal, the purchase agreement, any appraisal-gap language, the buyer's available cash, and what both parties are willing to do next.

So before anybody panics over one number, here is what the number actually means.

Why does the buyer's lender order an appraisal?

The lender is about to loan a lot of money using your house as collateral.

They want an independent opinion of the property's market value.

Freddie Mac describes an appraisal as a professional opinion of market value used by the lender to evaluate the collateral supporting the loan. Freddie Mac appraisal guidance

That is different from the home inspection.

The inspector is primarily looking at the physical condition of the house.

The appraiser is primarily developing an opinion of value.

Those two people can walk through the exact same house and be doing completely different jobs.

Also, not every financed transaction necessarily requires a traditional full appraisal. Some loans may qualify for an appraisal waiver or another permitted valuation method. But when a lender does require an appraisal, the lender controls that process—not the seller.

What is the appraiser actually evaluating?

An appraiser is not simply walking through deciding whether they personally like your kitchen.

They are analyzing the property and the market.

That can include things such as:

  • recent comparable sales
  • location
  • lot characteristics
  • square footage
  • bedroom and bathroom count
  • quality and condition
  • age and design
  • garages and other significant features
  • renovations and improvements
  • market conditions
  • differences between your house and the comparable properties

The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau explains that residential valuations commonly use information about the home along with sales of similar properties in the area. CFPB appraisal guidance

The result is still an opinion of value.

A professional, regulated opinion supported by data—but an opinion.

That distinction becomes important if the value comes in lower than the contract price.

Should I be home when the appraiser comes?

Usually, there is no reason for you to be.

Make the property reasonably accessible and let the appraiser work.

Your listing agent may provide relevant factual information such as a list of improvements, permits or documentation when available, and comparable sales they believe are useful.

What you should not do is follow the appraiser around explaining why every room is fantastic or trying to negotiate the value in real time.

And if you later disagree with the appraisal, do not start calling the appraiser directly and arguing.

Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac appraisal guidance routes valuation concerns through the lender's review process. Fannie Mae specifically requires lenders to maintain a reconsideration-of-value process for borrowers. Fannie Mae appraisal quality guidance

There is a process.

Use it.

What does a “low appraisal” actually mean?

It means the appraiser's opinion of value came in below the contract price.

That is all we know from that sentence.

Suppose you and the buyer agreed on $525,000.

The appraisal comes back at $500,000.

That does not automatically change your sale price to $500,000.

You still have a $525,000 contract unless the parties change it or the contract gives somebody the right to take another action.

The financing problem is separate.

Mortgage lenders commonly calculate loan-to-value using the lower of the purchase price or appraised value. For Fannie Mae purchase loans, for example, the property value used in the LTV calculation is generally the lower of those two numbers. Fannie Mae LTV guidance

That can affect the buyer's loan.

But here is an important detail:

A $25,000 low appraisal does not always mean the buyer needs exactly $25,000 more cash.

The actual impact depends on how much the buyer planned to borrow, their down payment, the loan program, mortgage-insurance requirements, and the lender's underwriting.

That is why the first phone call after a low appraisal should not be:

“So are they bringing $25,000?”

We need the buyer's lender to explain what the appraisal actually did to their financing.

Do I have to lower my sale price to the appraised value?

No.

You can agree to lower the price.

You are not automatically required to.

This is a negotiation governed by your contract.

Depending on the circumstances, the possible outcomes may include:

  • the buyer brings additional cash
  • you reduce the price
  • the buyer and seller split some of the difference
  • the buyer changes the financing structure if the lender allows it
  • the buyer asks the lender for a reconsideration of value
  • the parties use appraisal-gap language already in the contract
  • the buyer terminates if the contract gives them that right
  • the parties fail to reach an agreement and the transaction ends under the applicable contract provisions

There is no universal “low appraisal means seller drops the price” rule.

What if the buyer can bring more cash?

That may solve the problem.

A lender does not necessarily prohibit someone from paying more for a property than the appraised value.

The issue is how much the lender is willing to finance against the collateral.

Fannie Mae's consumer appraisal guidance lists increasing the buyer's down payment as one possible response when an appraisal comes in below the purchase price. Fannie Mae: Understanding Home Appraisals

So a buyer may choose to put more cash into the transaction.

But whether they can and whether they must are different questions.

Maybe the buyer has substantial reserves.

Maybe they were already stretching to cover the down payment and closing costs.

Maybe their loan program changes what is required.

Maybe bringing additional cash would affect reserves or another underwriting requirement.

We do not guess.

We get the lender involved.

What if the buyer asks me to reduce the price?

Then you have a decision to make.

Imagine:

Contract price: $525,000

Appraised value: $500,000

Buyer says:

“We want the price reduced to $500,000.”

You can agree.

You can say no.

You can negotiate something in between.

What makes sense depends on more than the appraisal.

Ask:

How strong is the evidence supporting the appraisal?

How much cash can the buyer bring?

What does our contract require?

What happens if we refuse?

Can the buyer terminate?

How likely is another financed buyer to encounter the same appraisal problem?

Have any new comparable sales appeared?

What will putting the home back on the market cost us in time, carrying costs, and uncertainty?

The correct answer is not always “hold firm.”

It is also not always “drop the price.”

Treat it like a business decision.

What does an appraisal contingency do?

That depends on the exact language in your purchase agreement.

Generally, an appraisal contingency can give a buyer certain rights when a required appraisal does not support the agreed price or financing.

Those rights might include an opportunity to renegotiate, provide additional funds, or terminate under specified conditions.

But contracts differ.

A buyer does not have some universal free-floating right to cancel every time an appraisal comes in one dollar low.

Likewise, a seller should not assume the buyer is trapped simply because both sides signed a purchase agreement.

Read the actual contingency.

The dates matter.

The notice requirements matter.

Any waiver or limitation matters.

The financing terms matter.

If the contract language is not clear, this is where legal advice is better than inventing an answer.

What is an appraisal gap?

An appraisal-gap provision is language the parties agreed to before the appraisal that addresses what happens if the value comes in below the purchase price.

Maybe the buyer agreed to cover up to $10,000 of a shortfall.

Maybe they agreed to cover the entire difference.

Maybe there is a minimum appraised value below which they retain additional rights.

Maybe the wording interacts with the financing contingency in a very specific way.

For example:

Contract price: $525,000

Appraised value: $515,000

Buyer agreed to cover up to a $15,000 appraisal gap.

On its face, that $10,000 difference may already be addressed by the contract.

But do not reduce appraisal-gap language to a slogan.

Read it.

The cap matters.

The calculation matters.

Any minimum value matters.

The buyer's proof of funds matters.

And the relationship between the appraisal language and the rest of the contract matters.

We already talk about appraisal-gap terms from the offer-comparison stage in How Do I Compare Offers on My House?.

Once you are under contract, the language you actually accepted is what counts.

Can we challenge a low appraisal?

Sometimes you can ask the lender to reconsider it.

That is called a reconsideration of value, or ROV.

But I want to be careful with the word “challenge,” because it can make this sound like we simply argue until somebody gives us the number we want.

That is not how it is supposed to work.

The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau says borrowers can ask for a reconsideration when they believe an appraisal is inaccurate, including by identifying factual errors, omissions, inappropriate comparable properties, or possible prohibited bias. CFPB reconsideration-of-value guidance

Fannie Mae's rules similarly say a request for a change in value should be based on material and substantive issues—not simply the fact that the appraised value does not support the desired loan amount. Fannie Mae appraisal quality guidance

That means a useful ROV might point out:

  • an incorrect square-footage figure
  • a missing bedroom or bathroom
  • a significant feature that was omitted
  • factual errors about condition
  • a comparable sale that appears materially more relevant
  • an adjustment that appears unsupported
  • other substantive appraisal issues

“Seller wants another $25,000” is not an appraisal deficiency.

Who actually requests the reconsideration of value?

Usually, the borrower works through their lender.

The seller is not the lender's appraisal client.

Your agent can help provide relevant factual information and comparable sales to the buyer's side when appropriate, but the request itself normally goes through the buyer and lender.

Fannie Mae now requires lenders to maintain borrower-initiated ROV procedures, and Freddie Mac has similar requirements. Fannie Mae ROV guidance

So if we believe there is a legitimate issue with the appraisal, we organize the evidence and work through the proper channel.

We do not harass the appraiser.

Will a reconsideration of value work?

Maybe.

Do not count on it.

Sometimes an appraiser or lender review identifies an error and the value changes.

Sometimes additional data supports a revision.

And sometimes everybody reviews the appraisal and the original value stands.

An ROV is not an automatic do-over.

It is a process for reviewing whether the appraisal is accurate and adequately supported.

If our entire strategy for saving the transaction is:

“The appraiser will definitely change it,”

we do not have a strategy.

We have optimism.

Can the buyer just order another appraisal?

Not as casually as ordering a second opinion on Yelp.

The lender controls the appraisal process and must comply with appraisal-independence and underwriting rules.

A lender may obtain additional appraisal work, a review, or another valuation in circumstances its guidelines allow, but a buyer generally cannot keep ordering appraisals until somebody produces the desired number and expect the lender to ignore the others.

A different lender could potentially have a different appraisal process, but changing lenders can affect deadlines, financing approval, costs, and the entire transaction.

Again: possible is not the same as guaranteed or wise.

What about FHA or VA appraisals?

Government-backed loans have their own rules.

A VA appraisal, for example, addresses both value and VA minimum property requirements. VA also has a formal reconsideration-of-value process and explains that when value is insufficient, potential options can include ROV, renegotiating the sales price, or the buyer bringing cash. VA home-loan guidance

FHA loans also have program-specific appraisal requirements.

That does not mean FHA or VA appraisals are automatically “worse” for sellers.

It means the financing program matters, and we need to understand the rules attached to the buyer's actual loan rather than relying on real-estate folklore.

If the appraisal is low, is my house actually worth less?

An appraisal is evidence of value.

It is not a divine proclamation.

A willing buyer already agreed to your contract price, which is also meaningful market information.

But if the transaction falls apart and the next financed buyer orders another appraisal, that next appraiser will still be looking at market evidence.

If there are few comparable sales supporting your price, the same issue can happen again.

If the first appraisal contained clear factual errors or ignored stronger comparable sales, another valuation could be different.

If a new strong comparable sale closes next week, that can change the available evidence.

So I would not say:

“The appraiser was wrong because we got an offer at $525,000.”

I also would not say:

“The appraisal says $500,000, therefore no human being can pay more.”

Look at the actual report, the market data, and your contractual position.

When can a low appraisal cause the transaction to fall apart?

Usually when the financing problem cannot be solved and the parties cannot reach an agreement.

Maybe the lender will not approve the planned loan at the contract price.

Maybe the buyer cannot or will not bring enough additional cash.

Maybe you will not reduce the price.

Maybe an ROV does not change the value.

And maybe the purchase agreement gives the buyer a right to terminate under those circumstances.

That combination can end the transaction.

What happens to the earnest money then depends on the contract and whether the buyer exercised a valid contractual right.

A low appraisal does not automatically mean you keep the earnest money.

For the seller-side explanation of that, see What Happens to the Earnest Money After I Accept an Offer?.

What should I do when my agent tells me the appraisal is low?

Do not immediately agree to a price reduction.

And do not immediately declare that you will never negotiate.

Get the facts.

Ask:

  1. What was the appraised value?
  2. Has the buyer or lender provided the appraisal or relevant information?
  3. What does the buyer's financing look like now?
  4. What does our contract say about appraisal and financing?
  5. Is there appraisal-gap language?
  6. Can the buyer bring additional cash?
  7. Are there legitimate factual or comparable-sale issues worth raising through an ROV?
  8. What happens if we cannot reach an agreement?

Then make the decision.

A low appraisal is a problem to solve.

It is not automatically a dead deal.

The bottom line

If your house appraises below the contract price, you do not automatically have to lower your price.

The buyer also does not automatically have to—or necessarily have the ability to—cover the entire difference.

The appraisal affects the lender's view of the collateral.

The purchase agreement determines the parties' contractual rights.

The buyer's finances determine what they can do.

And negotiation determines whether there is a solution everybody can live with.

Sometimes the seller reduces the price.

Sometimes the buyer brings more money.

Sometimes both sides move.

Sometimes a well-supported reconsideration changes the appraisal.

Sometimes it does not.

And occasionally the deal falls apart.

The useful question is not:

“Whose number wins?”

It is:

“Given the appraisal, the financing, and the contract we actually signed, what options do we have now?”

That is the conversation that gets transactions closed.

More on selling a home.

Start from the top of this topic: What Does It Cost to Sell a House in Spokane?

← Back to What's My Home Worth?