Skip to main content

Sellers

How Do I Compare Offers on My House?

By Billy Deese — Owner / Designated Broker

Published Updated

Seller reviewing printed offer paperwork with an agent at a table
Photo by Sora Shimazaki / Pexels (pexels.com/photo/5668858)

The highest offer is not always the best offer. Learn how to compare net proceeds, financing, earnest money, inspections, appraisal risk, contingencies, closing dates, and the buyer’s overall ability to actually close.

You get the text from your agent:

“We got an offer.”

Great.

Then another one comes in.

Even better.

Then you actually look at them and realize one buyer is offering more money but wants you to pay closing costs, another is putting more money down, another wants to close in three weeks, somebody waived an inspection, somebody needs to sell their current house first, and one buyer has an escalation clause that appears to require a minor accounting degree to understand.

Welcome to offer comparison.

The biggest mistake sellers make is assuming the highest purchase price is automatically the best offer.

Sometimes it is.

Sometimes it absolutely is not.

The better question is:

Which offer gives me the best combination of money, likelihood of closing, acceptable risk, and terms that work for my life?

That is what we are actually comparing.

Start with what you will actually walk away with

The purchase price is the first number everybody looks at.

It should not be the last.

Imagine you receive these two offers:

  • Offer A: $510,000 with the seller paying $15,000 toward the buyer's closing costs
  • Offer B: $500,000 with no requested seller credit

Before considering anything else, Offer B may actually put more money in your pocket.

That does not automatically make B the better offer either. There may be other differences.

But it illustrates the point:

Compare the net, not just the headline price.

Seller-paid costs can include things like buyer closing-cost credits, interest-rate buydowns, repairs, home warranties, or other negotiated expenses.

A buyer may also ask the seller to pay some or all of the buyer's real estate broker compensation. Broker compensation is negotiable and is not set by law. If you agree to pay it, that is another number that belongs in the comparison. NAR consumer guide on offers of compensation

Your agent should be able to lay the offers out in a way that shows approximately what each one means to your bottom line.

That is a lot more useful than circling the largest purchase price with a Sharpie.

Is a cash offer automatically better than a financed offer?

No.

Cash has advantages.

There is no mortgage lender underwriting the buyer. There is generally no financing approval that has to happen before closing. A lender is not requiring an appraisal as a condition of making the loan.

That can remove some moving parts.

But a cash offer can still contain an inspection contingency, appraisal provision, title contingency, sale contingency, or other contractual ways for the buyer to terminate or renegotiate.

And a sloppy cash buyer can absolutely be less appealing than a well-qualified financed buyer with a strong lender and clean terms.

So instead of simply asking:

“Cash or financing?”

Ask:

“What could prevent this buyer from closing?”

That is a much better question.

How much should I care about the buyer's preapproval?

Quite a bit.

A financed offer should normally come with evidence that the buyer has spoken with a lender and has been reviewed for financing.

A preapproval generally means a lender has looked at financial information—including credit—and estimated what the buyer may qualify to borrow. It is useful evidence that the buyer has done some homework, but it is not a guarantee that the loan will close. Consumer Financial Protection Bureau mortgage guidance

There is still underwriting.

There is still an appraisal.

The buyer still has to maintain their financial situation.

And the property itself has to qualify for whatever financing is being used.

This is one reason the name of the lender and the quality of the preapproval process can matter.

When appropriate, the listing agent may also talk with the buyer's lender to better understand where the buyer is in the process and whether the lender sees any obvious concerns—without expecting the lender to disclose the buyer's private financial information.

A strong lender saying, essentially, “We have reviewed this borrower thoroughly and they are ready to go,” is more useful than a PDF somebody generated online five minutes before writing the offer.

Does a bigger down payment make an offer better?

It can make an offer stronger.

But it does not mean you receive more money.

If one buyer puts 20% down and another puts 5% down, you still receive the agreed purchase price at closing if both transactions perform.

The down payment matters more as an indicator of the buyer's financial flexibility.

A buyer with substantial cash may have more room to deal with an appraisal issue, unexpected closing cost, or other problem.

A buyer using a lower down payment may still be extremely well qualified.

So I would never reject an otherwise good offer simply because the down payment is smaller.

We look at the whole financial picture.

What does the type of loan tell me?

Something.

Just not everything.

Conventional, FHA, VA, and other loan programs have different underwriting and property requirements.

For example, VA loans require a VA appraisal that addresses both value and minimum property requirements. The VA describes those requirements around whether the home is safe, sound, and sanitary. VA home-loan purchase guidance

FHA financing also has program-specific property standards.

That does not mean an FHA or VA buyer is automatically a weaker buyer.

It means we need to understand the property and the financing.

If your house has obvious condition issues, the loan program may matter more.

If the property is in good condition and the buyer is well qualified, the label on the mortgage may be far less important than sellers sometimes assume.

I would rather have a thoroughly approved VA buyer with a good lender than a poorly qualified conventional buyer whose financing is held together with hope and a preapproval letter.

How important is earnest money?

Earnest money matters.

But it is probably one of the most misunderstood pieces of an offer.

Earnest money is the buyer's deposit made in connection with the purchase contract. In Washington, earnest money is generally delivered according to the purchase agreement and handled through the broker or escrow process. Washington Department of Licensing real-estate resources

A larger earnest money deposit can indicate that a buyer is serious and has cash available.

But this is important:

A larger earnest money deposit does not automatically mean the seller gets to keep it if the transaction falls apart.

The contract matters.

If the buyer properly terminates under an inspection, financing, appraisal, or other contractual contingency, the buyer may be entitled to the earnest money back.

So when comparing earnest money, we look at both:

How much is there?

and

Under what circumstances is it actually at risk?

Those are not the same question.

What contingencies should I pay attention to?

A contingency is basically a condition built into the contract that gives the buyer certain rights if something happens—or does not happen.

This is where two offers with the same price can become dramatically different.

Some of the big ones include financing, inspection, appraisal, and the sale of the buyer's existing home.

The exact wording matters enormously.

A buyer who has several broad opportunities to terminate presents a different level of certainty than a buyer whose offer has fewer or narrower contingencies.

That does not mean “no contingencies” should automatically win.

Contingencies exist for legitimate reasons, and buyers who take unreasonable risks can create other problems.

The goal is to understand where each offer can break.

How much does the inspection contingency matter?

A lot.

The inspection period is one of the points where a transaction can potentially change direction.

Depending on the contract, the buyer may inspect the home and have rights to request repairs, negotiate, continue with the purchase, or terminate.

That means we want to understand:

  • Is there an inspection contingency?
  • How long is the inspection period?
  • What rights does the buyer have afterward?
  • Has the buyer limited those rights in any way?
  • Has the buyer already inspected the property?
  • Is the buyer waiving inspection completely?

A waived inspection can reduce one source of uncertainty for a seller.

But I would not boil the decision down to:

“Waived inspection = best offer.”

Suppose one buyer offers $490,000 and waives inspection.

Another offers $515,000 with a normal inspection contingency.

Whether that extra $25,000 is worth the additional uncertainty is a decision—not a mathematical fact.

That is why we compare the whole offer.

What about the appraisal?

This becomes especially important when an offer is substantially above what comparable sales appear to support.

A lender typically orders an appraisal because the property is collateral for the mortgage.

Suppose your house is listed at $500,000.

A buyer offers $540,000.

Fantastic.

But what happens if the appraisal comes back at $500,000?

That depends on the contract and the buyer.

Does the buyer have the right to renegotiate?

Can they terminate?

Did they agree to cover an appraisal gap?

If so, how much?

Do they actually have the cash to do it?

An offer at $530,000 with a meaningful appraisal-gap commitment could potentially be more reliable than an offer at $550,000 that becomes a completely different conversation if the house appraises for less.

The highest theoretical price is not terribly helpful if the contract gives us a clear path back down to another number.

What is an appraisal gap?

An appraisal gap provision generally means the buyer is agreeing, within specified limits, to bring additional cash if the appraisal comes in below the purchase price.

For example:

Purchase price: $525,000

Appraised value: $510,000

Buyer agrees to cover an appraisal shortfall up to $15,000.

That gives the seller more certainty than simply hoping the property appraises at $525,000.

But again, read the actual contract.

“Buyer will cover an appraisal gap” sounds impressive.

“Buyer will cover up to $5,000” is a very different commitment from “buyer will cover the entire difference.”

Details matter.

A lot.

What if the buyer has to sell their current house first?

Pay attention.

A buyer's sale contingency can introduce another entire transaction into yours.

Now your closing may depend not only on your buyer performing, but also on somebody buying their house.

That does not make the offer bad.

Plenty of contingent transactions close successfully.

But there is additional dependency.

Questions may include:

Has the buyer's house been listed?

Is it already under contract?

Has that buyer completed inspection?

How close is that transaction to closing?

What happens if their sale fails?

An offer from somebody whose home closes next week is different from an offer from somebody who says:

“We're planning to put ours on the market soon.”

Very different.

How much should I care about the closing date?

More than people think.

Maybe one offer closes in 20 days and another closes in 45.

If your house is vacant and you want your money, 20 days may be attractive.

If you need time to buy another home and move, a longer closing might be far more useful.

Maybe the buyer will let you remain in the house for a short period after closing.

Maybe you need possession through a particular date.

Maybe you're relocating and absolutely need the transaction completed before you start a new job.

Real estate is not Monopoly.

The goal is not simply to collect the largest number of dollars as quickly as possible.

The transaction has to work with the rest of your life.

A slightly lower offer with a perfect closing and possession arrangement can have real value.

What are seller concessions and why do they matter?

A seller concession is money or value the seller agrees to contribute toward certain buyer costs.

The most common example is a buyer asking the seller to contribute toward closing costs.

Depending on the loan and the buyer's situation, those funds may help cover lender costs, prepaid expenses, discount points, or an interest-rate buydown.

Different mortgage programs have different rules and limits on concessions. For example, Fannie Mae's conventional guidelines vary based on occupancy and loan-to-value, while VA rules distinguish ordinary closing-cost payments from concessions and generally cap defined seller concessions at 4% of the property's reasonable value. Fannie Mae interested-party contribution guidance

You do not need to memorize any of that.

Your job as the seller is simpler:

How much is the buyer asking me to pay, is their lender okay with it, and what does that do to my net proceeds?

That's the part that matters to you.

What if the offer asks me to pay the buyer's agent?

That is negotiable.

Buyer-broker compensation is not set by law, and a buyer may request that the seller pay some or all of their broker's compensation as part of the transaction. NAR consumer guide on offers of compensation

From your perspective, treat it like every other economic term.

What are you being asked to pay?

What is the overall offer?

What is your estimated net?

Do not compare a $510,000 offer with a seller-paid expense against a $505,000 offer without accounting for that expense.

Again:

Net beats headline price.

How do escalation clauses work?

An escalation clause generally says something like:

“I'll pay X amount above a competing offer, up to a maximum price.”

Example:

Buyer offers $500,000 but agrees to beat a competing offer by $2,500 up to a maximum of $525,000.

That does not necessarily mean you currently have a $525,000 offer.

The final number depends on whether the escalation language is triggered and exactly how the clause is written.

If you receive one, we need to look at:

  • the starting price
  • the escalation amount
  • the maximum price
  • what qualifies as a competing offer
  • what documentation may need to be provided
  • what happens with appraisal at the escalated price
  • whether the buyer has enough cash to support the result

An escalation clause can be useful.

It can also turn what looked like a simple one-page comparison into algebra.

We'll survive.

Should I just ask everyone for their “highest and best”?

Maybe.

If there are multiple offers, one strategy is to notify buyers that competition exists and give them an opportunity to submit their strongest terms.

Another strategy is to negotiate directly with one buyer.

Another is simply to accept an offer that already gives you what you want.

There is no universal rule requiring one approach.

NAR's guidance on multiple offers specifically recognizes several possible seller strategies, including accepting an offer, negotiating, or inviting buyers to improve their offers. NAR consumer guide on navigating multiple offers

Each option has tradeoffs.

If you push a strong buyer too hard, they can walk away.

If you accept too quickly, you may wonder whether another offer could have improved.

Our job is not to manufacture a bidding war for entertainment.

It is to choose a negotiation strategy that makes sense based on the actual offers sitting in front of you.

Do I have to take the highest offer?

No.

You are selling your property.

You can care about price, net proceeds, certainty, timing, contingencies, and other legitimate terms that matter to you.

What you cannot do is choose among buyers based on unlawful discriminatory factors.

Federal fair housing law prohibits discrimination in the sale of housing based on protected characteristics, and Washington law provides additional protections. HUD Fair Housing Act

That is one reason I am not a big fan of buyer “love letters.”

A letter talking about the buyer's children, religion, family, or personal background may reveal information that has absolutely nothing to do with the quality of the offer and may create unnecessary fair-housing risk. NAR has likewise warned sellers and agents about using personal buyer letters in offer decisions. NAR guidance on buyer love letters

I would rather compare the contract.

It is much more useful anyway.

What does the “best” offer actually look like?

There is no one answer.

For one seller, the best offer might be:

Highest net proceeds.

For another:

The offer most likely to close.

For another:

The buyer who will give them 45 days before possession.

And sometimes one offer wins almost every category.

When I compare offers with a seller, I want to answer four questions:

  1. What are you likely to net?
  2. How likely is this transaction to actually close?
  3. Where does the buyer have opportunities to renegotiate or terminate?
  4. Do the timing and other terms work for you?

Then we can make an informed decision instead of staring at the purchase-price line.

What happens after I choose an offer?

Depending on the situation, you may accept it as written, counter certain terms, reject it, or continue negotiating.

Until both sides reach agreement and the contract is properly executed, you do not have a completed deal just because everybody sounds excited.

And in Washington, your broker still has a duty to timely present written offers and communications even if the property is already subject to an existing contract. Washington RCW 18.86.030

Once you and the buyer reach mutual agreement, the next phase begins:

earnest money, inspection, appraisal, financing, title, closing, and approximately 47 emails containing the phrase “just circling back.”

We explain that entire stage in What Happens After I Accept an Offer on My House?.

The bottom line

The highest offer and the best offer are not always the same thing.

Price matters.

A lot.

But so do seller credits, financing, earnest money, inspection terms, appraisal protection, sale contingencies, closing dates, possession, and the buyer's ability to actually make it to closing.

We are not trying to figure out which offer looks most impressive on the first page.

We are trying to figure out which deal you actually want.

Because a $525,000 contract that falls apart three weeks from now is not necessarily better than a $515,000 contract that closes exactly when and how you need it to.

The goal is not just to get under contract.

The goal is to get closed.

More on selling a home.

Start from the top of this topic: What Does It Cost to Sell a House in Spokane?

← Back to What to Expect When You Sell